Leading Canadian
FRANCHISE & BUSINESS LAW FIRM

Lick’s Burger (Adlakha v. Meehan)

Full Case Name: Adlakha v. Meehan (2011)

This court decision is among the few Ontario court decisions relating to the enforceability of an arbitration requirement in a franchise agreement. It is the first decision holding that a franchisor’s affiliates, which are not parties to the franchise agreement, may be required to submit to arbitration together with the franchisor – even though they are technically not direct parties to the arbitration agreement.

The franchise agreement contained an arbitration provision, requiring the parties to submit all disputes between them to arbitration.

The franchisees sued not only the franchisor, Lick’s Burger, but also its numerous affiliated entities – none of whom was a party to the franchise agreement. The affiliates took the position that they were not required to submit to arbitration because they were not parties to the franchise agreement, and therefore the arbitration agreement.

The Ontario Superior Court (Commercial List) held that all entities which were alleged to be franchisor’s affiliates were required to submit to arbitration along with the franchisor. There were two main reasons: First, the wording in the franchise agreement consistently referred to the term ‘franchisor’s affiliates’ in association with the term ‘franchisor’. Second, Ontario’s Arbitration Act, 1991, gives an arbitrator broad powers to determine such issues.

Back

Franchise Law Blog

Seven Tips for Negotiating an Area...

Posted by | 25 June 2019

Authors: Ben Hanuka and Anthony Pugh, Law Works P.C. Read More

Supreme Court of Canada Rules Quebec...

Posted by | 20 June 2019

Author: Anthony Pugh, Law Works P.C. Editor: Ben Hanuka, Law Works P.C. In Modern Cleaning Concept Inc. v. Read More

Quebec Cleaning Franchise Agreement...

Posted by | 19 June 2019

Author: Anthony Pugh, Law Works P.C. Editor: Ben Hanuka, Law Works P.C. In Najah c. Read More

View All

What’s New

Sama Al Mutair and Sarah Ellen...

We are pleased to announce that Sama Al Mutair and Sarah Ellen McMahon joined Law Works as articling students as of July 8, 2019. Read More

Law Works successful in Court ...

We are pleased to announce that Ben Hanuka was successful as counsel in an appeal to the Court of Appeal for Ontario in an exclusive use dispute on behalf of Royal Paan, a... Read More

Ben Hanuka Quoted in Globe and...

We are pleased to announce that the Globe and Mail quoted Ben Hanuka’s opinion about the recent settlement in the Tim Horton’s class action. Read More

View All